Thursday, December 19, 2024

Economist argues that ban on gas exports may trigger retaliatory actions

Reading Time: 2 minutes
Imanuddin Razak

Journalist

Editor

Interview

The plan of Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan, the Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Investment, to continue the downstreaming policy by halting the export of liquefied natural gas (LNG), is considered high-risk for the country’s exports. This is because Indonesia could be perceived as engaging in trade protectionism, leading to retaliatory actions from its trading partners.

Bhima Yudhistira, the Director of the Center of Economics and Law Studies (Celios), expressed his concerns that if Indonesia impose more export bans, it could face legal challenges at the World Trade Organization (WTO) and its goods could be blocked from entering partner countries.

Bhima emphasized the need for the government to be prepared for the costly consequences of such a decision.

Bhima stated that the negative impact of trade protectionism retaliation could outweigh the benefits of downstreaming.

Moreover, the direction of the downstreaming policy is still questionable. For example, in the gas sector, he believes that the plan to ban gas exports does not align with the direction taken by various domestic companies that are starting to shift towards more environmentally friendly energy sources.

Support from businesses

Despite being considered as a high-risk policy and inappropriate by some, Luhut’s idea managed to gain the support of several business actors.

Bobby Gafur Umar, the Vice Chairman of Industry at the Indonesian Chamber of Commerce and Industry (Kadin), stated that the various downstreaming policies implemented by the government can stimulate industrial growth and bring added value to the country.

He emphasized that other countries have been processing Indonesia’s raw materials and enjoying added value for years, causing an opportunity loss for Indonesia.

Therefore, Bobby considers the ban on exporting raw materials, including natural gas in the future, as the right step.

By taking such measures, Bobby stated that the government can encourage global companies to relocate their factories to Indonesia and put more investments into the country.

Previously, the ban on exporting raw materials from Indonesia, related to the downstreaming program, received special attention from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

In their annual consultation report with Indonesia released on June 25, the IMF suggested that the Indonesian government should re-evaluate the ban on mineral exports in relation to the ongoing nickel downstreaming policy.

According to the IMF, the increase of foreign investment and nickel exports cannot confirm that this program brings more benefits than losses.

Banning export as a last resort

Meanwhile, Andry Satrio Nugroho, the Head of the Center for Industry, Trade, and Investment at the Institute for Development of Economic and Finance (Indef), stated that the IMF’s comments and concerns should prompt the government to consider downstreaming without simply banning the export of raw materials.

He believes that Indonesia has other options, such as implementing disincentives through price mechanisms, such as export duties or levies.

Andry argued that if the government only bans the export of raw materials, there could be cross-border impacts that indirectly affect Indonesia. Andry emphasized the need for internal strengthening measures and a good forward strategy in downstreaming, stating that the ban on exports should be a last resort.

Imanuddin Razak

Journalist

 

Editor

 

Interview

SUBSCRIBE NOW
We will provide you with an invoice for your reimbursable expenses.

Free

New to Indonesian market? Read our free articles before subscribing to the premium plan. If you already run your business in Indonesia, make sure to subscribe to the premium subscription so you won’t miss any intelligence & business opportunities.

Premium

$550 USD/Year

or

$45 USD/Month

Cancelation: you can cancel your subscription at any time, by sending us an email inquiry@ibp-media.com

Add keywords to your market watch and receive notification:
Schedule a free consultation with us:

We’ll contact you for confirmation.

FURTHER READING

A researcher has suggested the imposition of a transition period for the implementation of government-planned major reforms in the subsidized fertilizer distribution system.
The government has set an ambitious target to develop new and renewable energy (EBT) capacity of 103 Gigawatts in the next 15 years despite the realization of this target is hampered by the absence of regulations and supporting ecosystems.
Indonesia’s plan to increase the palm oil blend in biodiesel to 40 percent (B40) starting January 1, 2025 appears to be implemented gradually after industry players voiced the need for a transition period despite the government’s readiness for the policy rollout.
Eight residents of Rempang Island in Riau Islands Province were injured and dozens of motorized vehicles were damaged after dozens of people attacked local residents early Wednesday morning, December 18, 2024 over a land dispute in an investment project.
The Indonesian Steel industry needs to shift to low carbon technology in order to compete in global market, considering the iron and steel export value is higher than import and the European Union is determined to impose Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM), a research institution has suggested.
Coordinating Minister for the Economy, Airlangga Hartarto, has acknowledged that investment in Special Economic Zones (SEZs) in the tourism sector is still low due to minimum capital inflow as an impact of constraints on access to flight routes.